Science & Technology

Rave

Why Are People Capable of Great Goodness?

Posted 12 months ago|8 comments|590 views
Written by
Coloranter Raver
Denver, CO
If you've ever set about wondering why are people ever good, it's an interesting question. What exactly about the human brain and our emotional and physchological development would permit good traits to emerge. Obviously we are not all good, and many of us who are, aren't good all the time. One explanation that's been floated around for a long time is that man is good because he knows so being will please his maker. For the atheist this is a reacher unsatisfying explanation. It turns out, we may be good and have the capacity for so much good will based on the presence of special cells in our brains that actually allow for self-reflection and empathy called mirror cells.

Mark Matousek has written a great piece utilizing materials from his book, Ethical Wisdom: What Makes Us Good, entitled ("Why We Don't Need God to Be Good (and what religious folks don't want you to know") that explains both the mirror cells and what is known about them. He applies his wisdom and work to actual science available in the world and develops a compelling case not so much for the notion that God doesn't exist, but that we don't need the God-box to explain human behavior after all.
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
12 months ago: We are discovering new things all of the time that help us understand the physiological, environmental, and genetic reasons for becoming who we are, be that good or bad.

We have discovered a "Liberal Gene" "The 7R variant of DRD4, a dopamine receptor gene, has been associated with openness, a psychological trait that has been associated with political liberalism."

"Yet another study has tied a different gene to generosity or altruism. According to the study, a minute change in the so-called COMT gene, is associated with a significantly higher willingness to donate. People with this change gave twice as much money on average to a charitable cause as did other study subjects."

"Dopamine is involved in controlling social behavior in animals and humans. Thus the messenger, together with substances such as the neuropeptide vasopressin, influences sexuality and bonding. In addition, dopamine is linked with positive emotionality. Even the characteristic of being motivated by stimuli is controlled by this important neurotransmitter."

" Combined aggressive and non-aggressive behavior is frequent in both boys and girls. In boys it is related mainly to environment effects that influence both kinds of behavior, whereas in girls the combined behaviors appear related primarily to genetic factors."

Genetic deficiencies in the brain enzyme monoamine oxidase (MAOA) activity is tied to increased aggression. Females receive two X chromosomes, which means they have a much greater chance of getting at least one high-activity version of the MAOA gene. This may partially explain why women are less prone to violent and criminal behavior.

But all of these genes account for only about a third of the behavior. About two thirds of behavior is dependent on whether a person is loved and nurtured, or on the other side punished and abused.

"As adults, 85 percent of the severely maltreated children who also had the gene for low MAOA activity developed antisocial outcomes, such as violent criminal behavior,"

http://www.rantrave.com/Rant/The-Liberal...
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: Whatever it is mirror cells or anything else, I don't know.
I despise anything that hurts another person whether adult or child. For myself and my family, we never question why we help, we just do it and not think about it or want reward or recognition. Sometimes it does come, and it is a pleasant experience.
It would be perfect if just an ordinary American boy or girl could dream about being President one day and not have it so far out of reach as it has become today. Nurturing and raising a child well has nothing to do with being rich or poor just being there and setting an example makes all the difference. All you know when you are a kid is the affection and care that is provided. I like what both of you had to say. I wish more could see it that way. It would be a better place. I feel badly for the children that are raised with no understanding and only knowing the rod. Some people shouldn't be parents. It makes me mad. Thanks Sunny
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago:
"Friends" Season 5, Episode 4:

Joey: I'm sorry Pheebs, I just, y'know, I just wanted to do a good deed. Like-like you did with the babies.

Phoebe: This isn't a good deed, you just wanted to get on TV! This is totally selfish.

Joey: Whoa! Whoa! Whoa! What about you, having those babies for your brother? Talk about selfish!

Phoebe: What-what are you talking about?!

Joey: Well, yeah, it was a really nice thing and all, but it made you feel really good right?

Phoebe: Yeah. So?

Joey: It made you feel good, so that makes it selfish. Look, there's no unselfish good deeds, sorry.

Phoebe: Yes there are! There are totally good deeds that are selfless.

Joey: Well, may I ask for one example?

Phoebe: Yeah, it's… Y'know there's—no you may not!


http://www.friendscafe.org/scripts/s5/50...
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: Box - There is a big difference between acting, reality, and entertainment.
In reality people who are selfless don't even know they are. Everything they do is spontaneous and for the sake of giving.
I saw that episodeof Friends years ago, and it made a point.
In this one Phoebe didn't have to explain the why of her good deed.
How many soldiers have laid down their lives for their comrads because they wanted another to live?
How many leaders have fallen or great people taken the bullet for the sake of their Country.
How many have there been?
People that are gifted and have been lucky enough to be rewarded give back in life. I'm sure you give and don't even think twice about it. Look at the endless list of philanthropist that do not disclose their names and give to the sick and poor. For example, St Jude Hospital, the help that they get from people for cancer stricken children, and it goes on and on. To me this world is one big "gift basket" for people to help each other and some of us do what we can with what we have. I'm not sure what your point was here.
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: This is for Coloranter, Al, Box, and Truthbrary
This comment by Dick Van Dyke was on AOL PopEater.
I thought it had some bearing on humanities selflessness.

"You write a lot ….PopEater about spirituality and your search for meaning.
I would describe myself as curious. I've always been one of those people who are full of doubts. So I do a lot of research. I think there's been too much theological hairsplitting going on. So I try to keep it simple and leave the litany out. I keep going back to books by people like Martin Buber. I make notes in the margins. It's kind of fun to go back to a book I read 30 years ago and see what I was thinking about at the time. To live a life of love and compassion and to care about your fellow human beings and do no harm. I think that's a religion right there."
My father met this man years ago, and it was a nice experience for him. My father was a special man who never flaunted himself. Never felt because he had more that he was superior to anyone. Didn't have to he was self-made and strong and centered his attention on his Community.
Dick Van Dyke presents himself to me as a down to earth, considerate man who by his own self-admission is not perfect, but there is that humanity that exists that makes him special. Sunny
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
12 months ago: Sunny that was beautiful but it is too bad you hid it in a comment. That should have been your own post.

"To live a life of love and compassion and to care about your fellow human beings and do no harm. I think that's a religion right there." Good philosophy!

An Indian guru who just died, Sathya Sai Baba had a simple eight word saying that summarized his teachings: " Love All, Serve All, Help Ever, Hurt Never"
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
12 months ago: Sathya Sai Baba had a saying and Nazi Germany had a lovely democratic constitution.

This Sathyanarayana Raju who called himself Sathya Sai Bab didn't have any qualms about lying, wilfuly deceiving people, doing more magic tricks dressed up as miracles, in order to manipulate.

http://www.saibaba-x.org.uk/6/

sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: Thank you Al. I felt that you and the others would appreciate it, so I put it here. I tried to put this comment into my own post but couldn't do it correctly.
The Indian Guru you mentioned, Sathya Sai Baba, knew the secret of living life. A person comes full circle with that knowledge. I thought someone should mention Mothers to give them honor. Sunny
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.