Culture & Lifestyle

Rant

The Doormat: An Immigration Metaphor

Posted 12 months ago|30 comments|722 views
Written by
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
I have a WELCOME mat outside my front door. It just says WELCOME. Rather vague, not very wordy.

A pregnant woman broke into my home last week and delivered her baby there. Now she claims that since she was in my house, uninvited, at the time of the birth, that I, being the homeowner, am responsible for the care and upbringing of her child.

And to top it off, she says that since her child is now a part of my household, she has to stay in my house uninvited to care for the child, even though I'm the one footing all the bills for the child's education, medical expenses, and so forth. I'm not sure, but I think she has also invited a few of her sisters. It's a pretty big house, and I haven't seen them yet, but I swear sometimes at night I can hear them rustling around.

I went to the woman's mother to complain, to try to get the woman to go home, and the mother told me that she had instructed her daughters on the best way to break in, and where to find the refrigerator.

I went to my neighbors and told them of my situation. They said, "Well, did you have a mat out front that says WELCOME?" I said that I did, but that it didn't mean that just anyone could come in whenever they wanted and help themselves to my stuff, and stay indefinitely. It means that anyone that comes to my door and knocks properly is welcome.

They said "How do you know that's what it means? Were you there when the factory wrote WELCOME on the mat?" They went on to say "If the mat says WELCOME, then you must apply it to anyone, anytime. Why are you being such a racist?" They then went on to inform me that the mat was unchangeable, and that I wanted to change mats that have been that way for generations, just because I'm a homeowner supremacist.

"Change is good," they say, "except for that one. If you want that kind of change, you are a bad person."

I was getting a new mat made, one that more properly defined my terms. It was going to say something like, "If you are here peacefully, and intend to follow the rules of the house, and I have invited you here, or if you are in need and intend to ask for help and not demand it, and if you are willing to learn the ways of my household and not demand that my household change to accommodate your customs, then, and only then, after we have performed the necessary rituals of greeting, you are WELCOME."

Of course, I'll have to build a bigger front step to make room for the considerably larger mat.
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
12 months ago: I would say "Thanks" for the great post, but you might say....

"You are WELCOME" ...and you might not have enough room to respond !:]
12 months ago: After all I would like to head South for the winters...
or as long as you guys will have me !:]
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: You're welcome here anytime. I know you wouldn't break any laws in getting here.
12 months ago: Definitely not going to break any laws... I like the privileges of travel across one of the greatest nations in the "free" world... plus tax !:]
Paper Tiger
Paper Tiger
England
10 months ago: Hi Box, how's it hanging.

Whats's this about a welcome mat. Box I would expect you to roll out the red carpet.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
10 months ago: That's the thing. If I knew you were coming, I'd even bake a cake. It's hard to roll out the red carpet for someone if they sneak over in the dead of night.
12 months ago: This country was built over the graves of the indigenous and on the backs of immigrants both willing and not. Anyone who thinks to lay claim to it by virtue of birthright or by shade of skin claims only what his soul can carry.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: On the graves of many natives, yes. That was the way it was back then, there is nothing we can do to change it now. And on the backs of immigrants, yes again. Your forebears were immigrants, as well as mine. Through our blood sweat and tears was this country built. Even those brought into this country shackled and chained, whether white, black, or asian have benefited from this country's existence, if not directly, then through a better life for their progeny.

But that's all history, right? Just as the laws have evolved to take care of the people in their old age and need, laws need to evolve to prevent illegal overpopulation and further straining our dwindling resources. Just try moving to a any foreign country and claiming citizenship and benefits simply by virtue of you being there.

I still have to chuckle a bit whenever somebody feels compelled to throw the "shade of skin" slur around as a head wagging point. It's the same thing with the "Nazi" users. But believe me, your inference wasn't lost on me. Many differing "shades" can lay claim to this great country of ours through birthright: I won't even bother to list them, because it would be quite a lengthy list. As far as I know, any slaves brought over, white or black or asian or latino, have all died off. Anyone here who is a citizen is so because of birth, or because they went through the process, the same process required by any country.
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: You know what bothers me, Slim, people that were in the service of our Country but never went overseas and saw battle but claim it as they did. I see a big list online and one person in particular I know never left our Country but worked on a desk, and he is known for his questionable character. He is listed with Honor for serving his Country overseas in battle. It makes me sick.
Nobody checked it taken on his word apparently.
Paper Tiger
Paper Tiger
England
10 months ago: Hi Sunny2 my lovely friend

Good to see you. Why don't you disgrace that man as he is digracing orthers. He is taking their well earned respect that belong to hero's. Maybe he bought his pencil in Iran? Could that get him on the role of honour?
Paper Tiger
Paper Tiger
England
Content Removed by Paper Tiger
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
10 months ago: Relating to this post Paper? I was thinking of the guy from China.
sunny2
sunny2
10 months ago: Nice to hear form you Paper. Love to read some more of your poems.
Oh I see what you are referring to. I guess it is early for me. He is disgracing himself. You can only fool people for so long. He is getting it back. He uses that lie of being in battle for an excuse for bad, bad behavior so people will accept it and leave him alone to do what he wants.
12 months ago: Nothing we can do to change that? Really? Seems like we could still go a long way in making up for our past mistakes by building a non discriminatory system to allow for equal education, health care, opportunity and equal rights under the law.

History. right and by no means can it not be a part of the currency here and now. The laws you point to evolving to care for the aged or in need are the very laws the conservative right is looking to do away with.

There is no such thing as illegal overpopulation. At least not yet. And If I had been born in Canada I would have had dual citizenship in that country until my 18th birthday.

I'm not at all surprised that blatant racism makes you chuckle. Bigots often dismiss the idea of inequality as a joke. But as funny as you may think it is it still happens every single minute in this country either overtly or covertly.

While the original slaves are all long dead their progeny still suffer under a system designed to see to it that they never become as wealthy or influential as their whiter counterparts. A system of people who now wear the masks of concerned citizens trying to protect their country by the brown men of this world.

You know all in all I'm not an opponent to strengthening immigration policy. I am however sick of hearing how somehow the illegals are responsible for the problems this country face.

We dident mind using them to bend their backs in our fields or build our hoses at a discount we used them to make money because they worked cheaper then our citizens at jobs no one wanted. Now all of the sudden they have become the scurge of humanity.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: Sure, I find it funny when a white guy calls me a bigot. In my mind, the true bigot is the man who feels that minorities need a hand up or a hand out in order to be treated equally. He's also the guy who thinks that minorities need special consideration in order to compete in the marketplace and the education system.
See, I already know better. In my world, the minorities that have thrown off the shackles of your "help" are the ones who are getting ahead of the game. They don't consider themselves dependent on anyone else to achieve. They work hard, study hard, and save their money. Funny thing is, I actually would not have much of a living were it not for the minorities that I serve, most of whom are far and away more solvent than myself, and whose children will have every opportunity to excel in their own right. I don't even consider a person's skin color in any way. Every man is truly my brother and equal by word and deed alone. And that is why I have been to church, broken bread, laughed, lived, loved and mourned with black, latino, arab, asian, indian, and yes even white folks too. Most of my beloved friends have different skin colors and and different accents from me, and are here legally.

Illegal overpopulation not a problem to you yet?
Just look at California, whom you may be bailing out soon. As early as 2004, the cost of illegal immigration was costing the average household in California $1200/yr just for education, medical expenses, and incarceration. That's after considering the amount of income taxes the illegals might have been paying into the system. And that was not considering the incidental costs such as special language tutoring, special feeding programs, and additional welfare and unemployment paid to American workers displaced by illegal immigrants.

http://www.fairus.org/site/PageServer?pa...

Nationwide, way back in 1992, the estimated cost to taxpayers of all illegal immigration was somewhere in the $40-70 billion range. http://www.snopes.com/politics/immigrati...

12 months ago: I find it funny to read this statement...building a non discriminatory system to allow for equal education, health care, opportunity and equal rights under the law....

Yeah it would be nice it the white guys were treated fairly or equally.
12 months ago: Well I wasn't necessarily calling you a bigot but there we go. The number one claim of any Bigot is how he has eaten with and befriended members of other races. And how others who feel there is still inequality in the world are the true bigots. It's a classic symptomatic response.

Think there isn't inequality in the schools perhaps you should check the discrepancy between the school districts in richer and poorer neighborhoods.

Don't think there is any inequality in the job market? how do you explain the differences in pay rates between whites and non whites serving in the same positions?

So your saying it costs Californians about 3.50 a day per household to educate, and provide medical attention to illegals? Really doesn't seem like that much to me. Especially since we turn around and pay them half what we would otherwise to pick our crops and build our structures.

Illegals did not displace American workers in those jobs. Those jobs have always been done by Mexican immigrants. The amount of money funneled into the economy by illegals can not be counted. Many work with false social security numbers and their payroll taxes are dumped into the slush when they go undeclared. And unlike the majority of poor Americans, they cant get earned income credits or tax breaks.
12 months ago: Not too many illegals in KY? No need for them with only a hair ove 4 million in the entire population to either grow tobbaco or shovel the race hors poop.

Try this for your equallity. Just ask Julie. Since she "moved" from Mexico to the U.S.

http://www.dallasnews.com/news/education...

Now some of the students are graduating but unable to work legally as professionals. Julie, 29, who moved from Mexico to Austin at age 12, earned a degree in nursing from the University of Texas. She is unable to work, so instead she volunteers in Dallas.

You think Julie might be getting some other government help?

Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: "...Well I wasn't necessarily (man enough to call) you a bigot (outright) but there we go. (I'll just insinuate)..."

Until you have walked a week in my skin, been introduced by close "ethnic" friends as their brother, stood awkwardly by as close friends explained to THEIR prejudiced friends and relatives "he just looks white, he's really one of us", and been called "boo", "boyfriend", "my different son", then it's just a case of the pot calling the soup tureen black.

Schools: Why do you think "black" when you think of poor schools? It doesn't matter if it's a poor white school or a poor black school, there is going to a disparity between poor and rich. You should see our 80% black school's new $2.2 million astroturf field. Or the new $8.9 million freshman academy. Or the new $1.5 million strings academy. Or the new $850,000 soccer complex. And that's in a town of less than 70,000 people.

"... Illegals did not displace American workers in those jobs...."

I guess you didn't hear about the Howard Industries scandal, (592 illegal immigrants arrested in one raid, how many tomatoes do you think are growing in one of the world's largest transformer and computer manufacturing facility?) or the Marshall Durbin plant, or Colquitt County, Ga. Sanderson Farms. And don't tell me that Americans who need jobs won't take those positions. Just google "business fined for hiring illegal immigrants", and see how many of them are produce related.

http://immigrationlawyersnow.org/howard-...

Employer fines have plummeted for the hiring of undocumented workers. And yes, studies have been done considering the amount of taxes being paid by illegal aliens. People have been looking at it for thirty years and more. Taxes paid by the undocumented amounts to about 1/9th of the total cost to keep them here. And in California, most of their budget shortfall could have been eliminated by eliminating the illegal immigrant problem. Only now has the problem snowballed due to raising taxes and driving off their revenue base to try erroneously to make up the difference.

Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: "...Illegals did not displace American workers in those jobs. Those jobs have always been done by Mexican immigrants. ..."


This is an excerpt from a blog journal discussing the events at Howard Industries.


ICEFAN:
Yeah, I work at Howard Ind. and ICE finally came!!! It was awesome. Helicopter, hundreds of agents, made my day.

I.C.E. finally enforces our immigratin laws at Howard Ind. in Laurel, MS Not sure really of the exact numbers working at Howard's but it is well over a thousand for sure. All I can say is it is about time…Couldn't have come at a better time as the Company was about to break it off in us. We are currently renegotiating our contract with the company and with all the non-union illegal aliens that WERE working here we didn't have much of a foot to stand on. WE DO NOW!!!!…
I believe Mr. Humberto Gonzales (personal director, go figure) will probably end up being the patsy when all this is said and done. I'm sure the Howard's will be saying, "What? You mean they're all illegal? We never would have hired them if we had known that!" Yeah, V******V!! They knew they were illegal. They're a bunch of damn liars if they say otherwise…
hopefully, ICE stick around a while and try to get more. They've totally seized all the employee records, ka-ching!… This was better than Christmas. Hopefully, we'll be able to negotiate a contract which is fair, now that our replacements have been removed!!

…They were a few people short today. In fact, not a lot of transformers were manufactured today. I'm proud to say that there are plenty of job openings available. Lots of Americans are applying for jobs. On my way out of the plant today, I saw around 60 Americans anxious to be gainfully employed lined up in the hallway of the Personal Dept. Many more Americans from the surrounding area will surely be applying for jobs.

http://www.alipac.us/ftopic-129384-days0...
12 months ago: With all due disclaimers that metaphors have their limits, I like your metaphor, OOTB.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
10 months ago: Thanks Stan.
12 months ago: Don't forget to notify your insurance carrier.
12 months ago: Hey Red,

You talking to me? We do need to carry extra insurance... but it still is a hassle if something goes wrong... too bad that they don't have "stupid" insurance.. I have needed that a few times in travel !:]
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
12 months ago: I'm thinking RSG is talking about the fact that I'm gonna be required to pay for the health insurance of my uninvited guests. I'm not sure which will be cheaper: just letting them skate on their medical bills, or paying their premiums for them.
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: Box That is over the top way out of the norm. Don't welcome trouble.
I myself am a friendly person although when people visit they abide by my rules of respect for my home and property. Because if they don't and they hang around, they can destroy everything. I've turned my back for a moment and found some of my treasures gone when I had visitors. How can you accuse anyone without proof. Also, people with questionable character don't deserve help if they break down the fabric of your home. They don't sound too swift and don't deserve your respect.
You have to watch out for yourself first.
sunny2
sunny2
Content Removed by sunny2
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: I really enjoyed reading all the comments this morning. Good points.
Oh well, back to studies.
sunny2
sunny2
12 months ago: One more thing, how come they buried Bin Laden at sea so quickly. Why? They should of rocketed him out to space, but then he would of contamidated that. Well, I guess he will be polluting the ocean waters now. That scourge of humanity.
11 months ago: Love it, as usual OOTB.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
10 months ago: Much appreciated.
Ddraig
Ddraig
England
8 months ago: Extremely clever writing. An article I thoroughly enjoyed. Am a new user and am subscribing to you.
I look forward to reading other articles from yourself.

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.