Culture & Lifestyle

Rant

The Costs of Education and of Failure

Posted 18 months ago|7 comments|684 views
Only 47% of Black Males Graduate
Written by
Altruist
Eugene, OR
"The main hope of a nation lies in the proper education of its youth" - Erasmus

A recent study indicates that only 47% of black males graduate from High School compared to 78% for white males. In many of our big cities the graduation percentage dips to the lower 20's. In Detroit Whites actually do worse than Blacks. There, only 19% of white males graduate and 27% of black males graduate. You can see how your state does here: http://www.blackboysreport.org/

Many think that this is like the canary in the coal mine, and is an indication that our entire school system is in serious trouble.
http://www.thegrio.com/specials/making-t...

Since the economy is hurting, States are broke, and bankruptcies are epidemic, schools are also hurting. Many people blame the problems on the high salaries of teachers, but the average teacher salary is only $30,000. Many teachers are forced to supply paper, and pencils for their students. Now teachers are asking the students to bring in toilet paper because the schools cannot afford the basics. http://www.cnbc.com/id/38711521/Back_to_...

The stimulus funds helped save teachers jobs, and the recent bill that Obama just signed saves the jobs of another 160,000 teachers for a while, but the long term prospects are still troublesome. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/08/1...

The future of the nation depends upon the education of our children and currently our students do not compare very favorably when compared to the other developed nations. http://4brevard.com/choice/international...

The reason is not that we are not spending enough. If you compare the price we spend per student per GDP we are the third highest. Much of the disparity in education is because of lack of parental support and involvement. Some cultures value education more than others.
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/edu_sp...

In 2007 the average expenditure per student was $9,056, however those expenditures varied widely ranging from $5,048 in Alpine School District, Utah, to a high of $19,435 in Boston City Schools, Massachusetts.

The typical school district received 48% of their funding from the State, 43% from Local sources (mainly property taxes), and less than 9% from the Federal government.

You would expect that those States that spend more on education would have better academic performance than those that pay less, and that local school districts that have a more prosperous tax base would fare better than those that are impoverished, and that is true.

One report found that for every additional $1,000 spent per elementary student, proficiency rates rose 4 percent. They rose 8 percent on the same measure for middle school students. http://www.arizonaeducationnetwork.com/2...

As you would expect the affluent are happy with their luxury schools and the impoverished wish they could get better schools. The affluent justify this inequality by saying that they want "Local Control" of the schools. Naturally the better teachers gravitate to the school districts which pay the most, and which have the best facilities and the lowest teacher/student ratios.

The poorest school districts with the most crime, drug abuse, and broken families are also burdened with the least effective inexperienced teachers that can't get a job in the better school districts. The students in these school districts are often handicapped by crumbling buildings, lack of books and materials, language barriers, health and nutrition problems, lack of parental support, and drug, violence and crime problems. Is it any wonder that the students in richer school districts do better?

While the No Child Left Behind Program and now the Race To The Top Program provided much needed funding, these programs exacerbated the problems, because they treat the schools as businesses and the schools that do not perform well are penalized by having their funding cut. In fact the reverse should be true. Much more funding is needed for the poorer school districts to rebuild crumbling facilities, compensate for the poor environments, and to hire better teachers.

In 1954 Brown Vs Board of Education determined that segregation is unconstitutional. Today there is a different type of segregation, it is an economic segregation.

"Such disparities and relationships were viewed as violating the equal protection
clause of the U.S. Constitution, particularly if education was considered to be a "fundamental
right" (like the right to vote) guaranteed by the Constitution and district wealth
a "suspect classification" (like race) under the Constitution."

For that reason most states have programs of grants and other aid mechanisms to ensure that the students in poorer school districts have "adequate" educational opportunities. The Federal government also provides help to the disadvantaged through programs like Title 1, and programs like No Child left behind and Obama's Race to the Top program. Still schools have a long way to go before there is educational equity. The only way to provide educational equity is to have an equal cost per student nationwide, but that should be adjusted to account for different regional costs of living, and as I said the poorer troubled neighborhoods need additional resources to attract better teachers and to rebuild crumbling facilities and replace supplies.
http://futureofchildren.org/futureofchil...

There are many that think that they should not have to pay for the education of the poor. "If the poor are unwilling to work they deserve the consequences". They feel that they are only responsible for the well being of their own children or community, but we all end up paying for the nation's educational failures.

Partly because of the poor schools, about 30% of secondary students drop out. As we saw above that is much worse for minorities and in high poverty areas. Drop outs receive about $10,000 less per year than graduates, they pay less taxes, are more reliant on social services, have more family problems, and many become a burden on society because they are much more prone to crime. While schools only cost about $10,000 per student, prisoners cost about $22,000 per year. On average each drop out costs the nation about $260,000. http://www.all4ed.org/files/archive/publ...
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
17 months ago: Really? the "Average" salary for 9 months of work is 30 thousand dollars?

Really? Don't you mean beginning "entry level" teachers?

Try searching the facts for your own state.

http://www.teachersalaryinfo.com/average...

Most are well above 30 thousand for nine months of work.
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
17 months ago: Good catch. Must have been an older article I grabbed that from.

Times have changed. My first full time contract was $11,000. Back then all the teachers had to get summer jobs to survive.

I still think that teaching is one of the toughest jobs around. They earn their money and often have to take courses during the summer to stay current.
17 months ago: Yeah. Right.

Whoa, Wait.....

Teachers had to get "Summer Jobs" to survive becase the were not work during the summer?

Your breaking my heart.
THE RONBOT HUNTER
THE RONBOT HUNTER
17 months ago: Altruiesta said

"Since the economy is hurting, States are broke, and bankruptcies are epidemic, schools are also hurting. "

Why do you lie in other posts and comments saying that all is well with the country.

That Obama has brought us back, that Obama has restored America, that there is no need for change?

How can people that don't know that you are our resident communist here, believe in you?

QUESTION OF THE DAY FOR HUMAN BEINGS TO ANSWER.

The Commie Bleeding Heart Liberal is the child molesters and rapists best friend and protector.

The conservative American is the child molesters and rapists worst enemy.

To protect your women and children, who would you vote for?

Who would you believe, trust and support?

To know the mind of the commie liberal is to know the truth

To Really Know What A Commie Liberal Is, Just Know What They Stand For -- They Are ONLY For:

Anti-Self Defense, Anti-Second Amendment, Anti-Constitution, Anti-Real Constitutional History, Anti-Family Values, Anti-Business, Pro-Big Government, Pro-New World Order, Pro-Criminals, Anti-Natural Nutrients, Pro-Excessive Taxation, Pro-Excessive Federal Regulations, Pro-Abortion Or Anti-Life, Anti-Real Causes Of Illnesses And Pro-Symptom Cures, Anti-Natural Doctors And Pro-Symptom Doctors, Anti-God, Anti-Religion, Pro-Godless Cults, Anti-Patriotism, Pro-Corruption, and Pro-Immorality, Pro-Perversion, Pro-Bestiality, Etc., And Etc..

When We Have Commie Liberals In Control, We Don't Need Plagues, We Have The 666 To Rule Us.

By knowing how their sick minds work. Can you trust them? Do they ever tell the truth?

I tell it like it is, I pull no punches, tell no lies, and I am as I am

THE ONE AND ONLY RONBOT HUNTER
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

http://movielocker.com/5232 -- installs the viewer

http://www.powercrossing.com/ plays the video on "What happened to the constitution?"

http://www.zshare.net/video/770741931126...

THE RONBOT HUNTER
THE RONBOT HUNTER
Content Removed by THE RONBOT HUNTER
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
17 months ago: Ron Obama has recognized that the nation is hurting, which is why he asked Congress to give tax breaks to 95% of the people (opposed by all but 3 Republicans), extend unemployment payments, (which was filibustered for 3 days by the Republicans), why he asked for tax breaks to small businesses (which was defeated by the Republicans filibuster), and why he asked Congress to provide the aid to the states so they can keep their teachers. At least Obama and the Democrats are trying to help the situation. All the Republicans can do is obstruct every attempt at helping the people.

As for being able to trust me and my opinions, all I ask is that you read the supporting links that I provide.

I am glad that you continue to post your opinions Ron. It provides a good counterpoint. On the one hand I try to provide rational arguments based on facts, while you provide hysteria and hate mongering based on nothing but the opinions of fellow violent whackos.
BruceDPrice
BruceDPrice
Virginia Beach, VA
17 months ago: I'm betting that Altruist, with beat-up books in a run-down garage, could out-teach virtually every public school classroom in America, at one-quarter the cost. It's all a question of seriousness of intent. Are the people in charge sincerely trying to educate? (Or are they committed to indoctrination?)

I'm amazed anybody with his brains would provide cover to the duplicitous Education Establishment. All you have to do is look at Whole Word, New Math, Reform Math, Constructivism, Cooperative Learning, Self-Esteem, Multiculturalism, No Memorization, Authentic Assessment, and about 100 other gimmicks, and you know these people are not sincere.

The paradigm for all their malfeasance is Whole Word. It's a great portal into the dark heart of American public school education. Virtually nobody becomes a fluent reader using this method, and so we have 50,000,000 functional illiterates. What else do you need to know?


(For more about Whole Word, see "42: Reading Resources" on Improve-Education.org.)
http://www.improve-education.org/id65.ht...
17 months ago: Whoa. Noboby said Alturist was not smart. I think the term is "Brainwashed".

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.