Culture & Lifestyle

Rant

Pet restrictions

Posted 36 months ago|6 comments|1,680 views
Written by
I just bought a house. Well, *technically* it's a duplex condo, but it's mine, I bought it.

The way things work with a condo is that I own and am responsible for the inside, while the Home Owners Association owns and is responsible for the outside. I own the interior walls, and everything that those surround. I do not own the outside walls, the roof, or the grounds. But I pay someone to keep all that maintained.

The thing that peeves me is that because I'm apart of this HOA, they feel they have the right to tell me what I can and can't have inside my house. One of those being a pet.

Now, it's cool that they keep tabs on what goes on in this Association... you know, so we don't have crazy cat women or puppy millers living here, but if I want two dogs and a cat, I can't. Why? Because there is a two animal limit while living here. Another thing is that if I wanted one animal, but say it's a Mastiff or a big German Shephard Dog, I can't. Why? Because those dogs get over 75 pounds. That's the weight limit on dogs here.

What!? I OWN my own home here. I own this inside of it! I pay my mortgage and dues on time every month, I don't have 16 cars sitting in my driveway and front yard, I don't have broken or boarded up windows, heck, I even make sure all my front porch lights work! But if I want to own a big dog, I can't.

The reason I don't understand this is as follows:

The dog is going to live IN my house. Don't I own the inside of my house? I'm not planning on keeping it on the roof, which they own, or in the middle of the street, which they maintain. No. It will live in MY dwelling. So who are they to tell me how big of a dog I can have in MY HOUSE?

Now, you could argue that big dogs damage and soil the yard more than a little or medium sized dog, but do they? Really? A big dog's poo will be bigger, but if I were to leave a little dogs poo in the back yard, it's going to get just as gross out there as if I left a big dogs. (except you can see a big dogs poo to avoid, not a little dogs!) If I left my little dog outside in the yard, it can dig and tear up the yard just as well as a big dog, if not more so. Big dogs are much more calm then little dogs, they will calm down sooner than a little dog and won't yap all day long.

Anyway, it peeves me. I think I should be able to own as many animals I want, as long as it stays sanitary, or as big of a dog as I want IN MY OWN HOME. I don't know who came up with the idea of a Home Owners Association, but they were dumb. And that's all I have to say about that!
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
36 months ago: Yeah, we looked at the restrictions before purchasing. We weren't going to pass on this house just because of the pet restrictions. We got the house for about $25 thousand less than the asking price, and it fit our search perfectly. And just because I want a dog that tops out at about 125 lbs doesn't mean I'm going to pass on a house that in every other sense is perfect! I can just get a smaller female of the same breed, and keep her on the lean side! Problem solved :)
amishking
amishking
 Moderator
Auburn, NY
36 months ago: First of all, congratulations on getting your house! I am putting in a purchase offer on one today myself. I hope it's your dream home. Second, can you talk to the condo board and rewrite the dog rule? Your solution about getting a lean female makes sense. Maybe you ask the condo board to list which breeds are acceptable, and then amend it later. Just a suggestion.

Again, Congrats. May God bless your home.
glitchypetpeeve89
glitchypetpeeve89
Auburn, NY
36 months ago: I think they are more concerned for "their" lawn than the inside of your home which is owned by you.
Coloranter Raver
Coloranter Raver
Denver, CO
36 months ago: Howleane: I would like to let the benefit of experience be your guide and let you know that the pet rules in most HOAs were created to protect you and your investment. You might not see that now, but 10 years from now, if you hold onto your home for the length of time recommended such that you realize a profit from its sale, you will be very glad for such rules.

First, this is something pet owners don't want to hear, and I'm sorry, but any real estate agent will tell you that pets, no matter how small, decrease your property value. If you care about your long-term earnings potential from owning your own home, you wouldn't have any pets. However, having smaller pets impacts your home value less than larger ones as does having, obviously fewer pets.
Coloranter Raver
Coloranter Raver
Denver, CO
36 months ago: Second, so you might ask, so what if I reduce my own property value, it's my property. True, but when you live in a condo, your value has an immediate impact on every other condo. Just like if a home sells for $20,000 less than market in a neighborhood it drags down the sale price of all neighboring homes. When or if you go to sell, you're not going to want to hear that your condo would be worth $15,000 more were it not for the fact that the dog-damaged condo across the way sold for $20,000 less than it would have. Banks, when doing mortgages, also factor these things in. They need to ensure that the property, should you default--which you won't but people do--will be able to be sold for enough to cover your remaining mortgage. Which of course I hate to remind people that when they "buy" a house, unless they are a Rock Star, they generally own very little of it, with the Bank owning the bulk, and that's not beside the point as it might seem. A good bank is less likely to approve your mortgage if there aren't pet rules in a condo building, both because they care about your/their value, but also because they don't want other people ruining your/their value.

When you buy your first house, usually the last thing you think about is selling it. But, it ought to be the very first thing on your mind before you buy. Because if you're never going to be able to sell it (bad neighborhood, bad location, bad layout, bad pet damage,) then you may as well rent. You'll be a lot better off in the short and long run.

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.