News & Politics

Rant

Nun excommunicated for allowing abortion

Posted 21 months ago|5 comments|483 views
Written by
RLwoods
Victorville, CA

How far should a doctor go to save a life? What if its a Catholic hospital?
Sister Margaret McBride, the administrator of St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix, thought that nothing should be spared in her hospital.

A woman entered into the facility, 11 weeks pregnant with her fifth child,with major heart problems, she was said to have by hospital documentation "right heart failure".

the doctors told her that she was very sick, and that her risk of dying was extremely high. The only way that she stood a fighting chance was to eliminate the stress on her body from the pregnancy. The woman agreed to terminate the pregnancy.

St. Joseph's, is a catholic hospital, and the stance on abortion is quite clear, and many thought that it was the churches position to allow both mother and child to die. This was not a path Sister Margaret McBride was willing to take.

she allowed the abortion to take place, she saved that woman's life.
The number one goal of the medical profession, save lives.

News of this spread all over the area, and it was not long until Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted found out. When Bishop Olmsted found out, he proceeded to punish Sister McBride with the most he can allow. She was excommunicated. Sister McBride was excommunicated, for doing the one thing that she felt was right.

How awful is this, She has done all in her power to devote her life to her religion, and when she must make the difficult choice of allowing an innocent person to die and violate all that her medical center is for, or choosing to save their life, which she thought that the church would have supported her on.

I don't think anyone would want to make that choice, but she did without hesitation.
She did it without hesitation because of Directive 47 in the U.S. Catholic Church's ethical guidelines for health care providers, this allows for that very decision that she made. To preserve the mothers life.

She felt that with this, the church that she devoted her life to would thank her for making the decision, but instead, she receives the harshest punishment imaginable.

Where has the soul of the church gone? Why is it doing this? Has the world around it become so jaded, that it has made the church forget why they believe Christ died for their sins?

it appears that some members of the church have accepted the policy that rules and protocol are more important than compassion for people in difficult times.

for the original article follow the link:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story...
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
markbyrn
markbyrn
 Moderator
21 months ago: This story doesn't fit the template of the so called 'pro-lifers' agenda- so they'll bury it.
21 months ago: There have been plenty of other situations where the mother's life was in apparent jeopardy, yet mom decided to go through with the delivery and mommy and baby came out fine.

I'm a pro-lifer. However, each individual involved has their own life and has to make their own ethical and legal choices. After that they simply have to deal with their own fallout. And there always is some.

20 months ago: I am sorry but I do not agree she should of made this choice. We of faith have to remember God can intervene. We do not live as the world lives. I hate abortion, that child in my eyes was murdered and it is wrong. It should not be a option.
RLwoods
RLwoods
Victorville, CA
20 months ago: Not to criticize you, but i have to ask this out of pure curiosity.
in the article that i linked to, the doctor is supposed to have said that her chance of mortality was near 100%, and that eliminating the abortion would be her only chance to live.

do you honestly belive that the hospital should have let her die? dont you think that allowing that on religious reasons is against everything that hospitals are fore?

aren't they there are to make the best out of a bad situation? if the outcome of her dying is almost certain, why not save at least one of them?

20 months ago: RLwoods

Dr's are wrong many times. So who is to say that his judgement is right. I had a child that was born very tiny. I carried to 26 weeks with no amniotic fluid, the placenta was hanging on by a thread. I bled so much that I could not even walk. The Dr'd assured me this baby would not live. Would be born with severe health issues. Over and over again I was told I should abort. I stood firm in my faith and said no it was Gods choice. Even days before I delivered they all once again said just to abort. I myself was very weak, from all the blood loss and they emergency transfused me.

After he was born at 1lb4oz he head a few problems, yet as soon as the Drs spoke them, they would in a day be gone and he was okay again.

To make a long story short, this little guy just turned 5. He is healthy as a horse. Smart, clever,funny and has not one health problem.

I have heard many stories like ours.

So are Drs right all the time?

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.