News & Politics

Rant

Muslim Woman fired for Wearing Hijab

Posted 23 months ago|15 comments|1,706 views
VIDEOS
Written by
Rudi Stettner
 Moderator
Abercrombie and Fitch proudly cites its commitment to diversity in the workforce. Hani Khan, a Muslim sales clerk found out that this commitment has its limits. The Contra costa Times reports as follows on the firing of the Muslim sales clerk from hollister's, a subsidiary of Abercrombie and Fitch.


"Except, last month, at Hollister, the spinoff of Ohio-based Abercrombie & Fitch that she says fired her for wearing the hijab at work almost five months after she started there. A week before her termination, during a meeting with a district manager, was the first time in her life someone had confronted her -- not just out of curiosity -- about her Islamic garb.

"She called us from there and said, 'Come and pick me up,' " said Khan's father, who asked that his full name not be used in concern for his family's safety. "She was really upset."

Ms. Khan had been hired despite an elaborate dress policy that covers everything from hairstyle (no cornrows) to footwear. (sneakers and sandals required) The company promotes a young, hip image. Ms. Khan lasted for five months. Her conflict was not at a local level but with corporate headquarters. It should be noted that she was not covering her face, but only her hair.

Companies like Abercrombie and Fitch have a strong influence upon the development of fashion in America and in the world. Although the reaction may be delayed and modified, even communities that are out of the mainstream such as Muslims, Chassidic Jews and Pentecostals absorb modified versions of mainstream fashions. Those whose business it is to set fashion trends are not working with a blank slate. Ms. Khan is a living reminder of this. The very fact that she felt comfortable applying for a job at Hollister's shows that her personal interpretation of Islamic law and culture had shifted to an acceptance of American style to some extent. While Europe has polarised over the integration of Muslims into European society, America has experienced a far less traumatic process of integration.

Ms. Khan accepted enough of the Abercrombie and Fitch wardrobe to be able to commit herself to promoting their merchandise. If she were to cover her face and wear a shapeless robe, one could make the case that she is not an appropriate model of the Abercrombie and Fitch image. This was clearly not the case. One can see many Muslim women in New York, San Francisco and elsewhere who blend modern fashion with the strictures of Islamic modesty.

The precedent that is set by firing Ms. Khan is a bad one. America has evolved into a haven of tolerance for different religious groups. The danger that is posed by her termination from Hollister's could spread beyond the Muslim community and effect others. That is how legal precedent works.

The Contra Costa Times quotes a young Muslim woman as follows concerning Islamic dress codes.
"As Muslims, we believe it's God's order to cover ourself and dress in a certain way," said Alaa Suliman, a 27-year-old engineer who has always worn a hijab, without incident, at her Silicon Valley jobs. "It also means you're not looked at as a sex object. It's not about your physical attraction."


I have heard Orthodox Jewish women and devout Christians voice almost identical sentiments with support from their respective scriptures. Modesty is not a Muslim monopoly. The need for it and the desire for the protection and ennoblement it affords society transcends religious boundaries.

Hani Khan should not have been fired. She should be given her job back. And American courts should protect her rights. Because they are ours as well.


Reprinted with permission from Magdeburgerjoe.com

http://www.contracostatimes.com/bay-area...

Shop from the links with this article as well as those on www.magdeburgerjoe.com and www. rudistettner.com
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: This is terrible. She clearly should not have been fired with no warnings about hte issue.

Also terrible is the fact that this will not get any main stream media coverage because she was Muslim. Just imagine if she was Christian; Bill O'Reilly and Glen Beck would be all over this and everyone in the nation would have heard about it 100000 times already.
markbyrn
markbyrn
 Moderator
23 months ago: One of the most intellectual if not incendiary of right wing talk show pundits, Michael Savage believes that Hani is a CAIR plant who applied for the job specifically to sue for the money and to quote him,

"Why would a devout believer of any religion apply for a job at a place like A&F? It would be like a vegetarian applying for a job in a butcher's shop. Common sense would tell you not to do it, unless you have other motives."

While I hate to admit it, I actually had that thought in mind before I found the Savage comment. Not that she was a plant, but why would a devout Muslim woman work for a company that promotes indecent standards of dress (by Muslim standards), especially by women? In fact if you head over to abercrombie.com, you'll see for yourself.

...This is terrible. She clearly should not have been fired with no warnings about the issue...

I find that hard to believe that she was fired with no warning. According to what I read, she was fired for refusing to remove her scarf and the company has a dress code which is quite warranted considering the business they're in. What is difficult to understand about that?

...Hani Khan should not have been fired. She should be given her job back. And American courts should protect her rights. Because they are ours as well...

Sorry Rudi, she doesn't have an inherent right to work at A&F and if she fails to comply with their dress or look policy, goodbye - find another job. What's next Rudi - are you going to say that a woman wearing a burqa has a fundamental right to work at Hooters as a waitress?
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: They had no problem hiring her while wearing the scarf. They never mentioned it was an issue until they fired her...
markbyrn
markbyrn
 Moderator
23 months ago: ...They had no problem hiring her while wearing the scarf. They never mentioned it was an issue until they fired her...

If that's what actually happened, I'd agree there might be a genuine grievance. Were you an eyewitness to this? As I read the story in the SF Chronicle, it said she refused to remove the scarf. That's not quite the same as being fired without warning.
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: My issue is that they hired her, she worked there for some time without an issue, then someone else from the company came in and said to remove it. She never should have been hired if the scarf was against the dress code and this is where I see the legitimacy in her claim.
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: They had no problem hiring her while wearing the scarf. They never mentioned it was an issue until they fired her...
markbyrn
markbyrn
 Moderator
23 months ago: I kind of sort of agree but at the same time, if the policy was clearly written and simply not being enforced at the SF office, it doesn't mean that a senior corporate HQ manager can't suddenly and legitimately enforce the policy. That's called management.

Now if the policy is written in a manner that suggests they allow all manner of dress except for anything religious (e.g. Hijab, yarmulke, etc.) or especially a policy that that targets one religion, than we might have a legit grievance here.
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: For the first part...Actually if the policy hadn't been enforced then there still would have had to been documented warnings since she was never made aware of the policy in the first place.

I agree with you on the second part. If the policy says absolutely no religious symbols at all then its fine. But I have seen a huge number of employees at those stores wearing crosses and they never get fired.
Rudi Stettner
Rudi Stettner
 Moderator
23 months ago: One thing I share with observant Muslims is a desire to filter the cultural mainstream. I observe the way Muslim women dress in my city and I see an effort to balance fashion with modesty. The same balance is being attempted by orthodox Jewish women. Many orthodox Jewish women and girls shop at mainstream shopping outlets for clothes. The same is true for Muslim women as well. With clothing as with food, there are forbidden items sold. How did the Muslim girl square this with her convictions and with her imam? I don't know. It is a mistake to believe that all Muslims are alike. There are liberal imams who actually allow alcohol as long as you don't pray while drunk. And some of the ones that look like real holy rollers practice sighe, or temporary marriages, which leads to real abuses

http://www.library.cornell.edu/colldev/m...

There are Shiites and Sunni as well as some murderous rivalries. The Saudis are subsidising mosques and religious training for imams. That is another source of subversive forms of Islam. But it is a mistake to impute unity to Muslims. You have the laid back Albanian Muslims and then you have some real far out people who are promoting the burka, which shows only the eyes. There are even a couple of villages in Saudi Arabia where men are never allowed to see the face of their wife. One such women told her husband that she would rather he take a wife from another village than to see her face. Over here, we tend to lump people like that with the more modern Muslims. I believe that this young lady deserves her day in court. She is defending freedoms that I want for my family and for religious Christians as well. I do not want to have a wahabi outbreak in America. I believe that the way to prevent this is by recognising the diversity within Islam and by treating Muslims as individuals.
23 months ago: HUH? Mark? Am I reading all of this correctly? It's OK to dress like a SLUT as long as your hair is covered?
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: Where does it say that she was dressed like a slut? There are plenty of Muslim women who wear designer jeans and t shirts that still cover their hair with a scarf...as usual you just ramble on with comments that add nothing to a conversation.
markbyrn
markbyrn
 Moderator
23 months ago: I don't know - I'm kind of torn on this issue. Even if she dressed modestly, she's working for a company that ostensibly sells slutware and chic gay fashion. Reminds me of when I was stationed in Turkey and while the Muslims abstained from pork, they would happily cook it for us infidels. I guess religious fantasy tends to breed these type of paradoxes.
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
23 months ago: I guess that depends on the definition of "Slut", which would vary greatly from person to person I would imagine. (my definition and redstateguy and Cypress's definitions would be vastly different I would assume)
THE RONBOT HUNTER
THE RONBOT HUNTER
23 months ago: The company is way out of line. This was not a matter of a dress code of indecency, but of racism.

The US has allowed the world to think that it is a Nation of double standards.

The Muslin world has to strike back in the same way.

Sadly I know that if they do it, the US will not change but get worst.

But honor has no shame. Maybe the US will get the message, that to punish innocent people has a price.

What goes around, comes around.

THE RONBOT HUNTER
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

http://freedom-school.com/law/prison_tre...

http://freedom-school.com/keating/how-a-...

Rudi Stettner
Rudi Stettner
 Moderator
23 months ago: The ads that pop up with this post reinforce my conviction that some of the moderate fashions from the Islamic world would have impacted on American fashion had it not been for 9/11. There is nothing wrong with covering up in an elegant and not awkward way. Some Islamic fashions. (baggy but feminised pants under a kameez afford greater freedom of movement to the women who wear them. Unfortunately, because fashions are about politics and group identity, some very reasonable fashions from the Islamic world will not get the respect they deserve. I feel that this is unfortunate

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.