News & Politics

Rant

Military worried about soldiers that are "too fat to fight".

Posted 19 months ago|2 comments|539 views
Written by
RLwoods
Victorville, CA
There has been an new question posed by the pentagon recently. This question was of an interesting prospect of the future for our military. The question was strange, it did not deal with army growth, or the number of recruits, but on the nutrition of the recruits, and they are wondering how it effects them. The pentagon wants to know, will we at a near point in time have soliders that have such poor nutrition that they will have soldiers that are to overweight to fight?

The military is not passivliy asking this, they are actively getting involved in this. They released a report that was made by several retired military leaders, the report was aptly named, "too fat to fight".

They along with releasing this report are also getting involved with different legislatures trying to reinitiate the "child nutrition act" which would regulate and remove a large portion of the junk food from school cafeterias.
This is almost the exact opposite of what the act was originally designed for, as it was designed to help children get enough to eat and keep them healthy and well fed.

This was looked at heavily when they studied the data from the center of disease control and prevention stating that over %27 of young adults are to overweight to join the military.

The reports stated that in 1998 only Kentucky had a population with more than %40 overweight. Now it is only 10 states that are under %40 and three states that have over % 50 overweight populations.
One thing that bothers me here is that one would think that being the military, they could have a program for overweight people. Mandatory calisthenics for starters, I know the military has basic standards but I would think that this would be a basic one.

They can't really eat all they want to in the military, and I doubt that even the most stubborn of men would be able to keep up their fatty diet with two sets of PT.
I really don't see this as too much of a problem for our military, however they do, and it is their show, so they really should be able to have a say in what is and what is not fit to join.

For links to other articles I've written
http://rlwoodsiii.blogspot.com/
For the original report.
http://cdn.missionreadiness.org/MR_Too_F...


EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
19 months ago: Because of budget cuts, Physical education programs are among the first to be cut.

Also school nutrition and lunch programs rely on government surplus food supplies that are mostly high fat and white flour.

Besides worrying about people being too fat to dodge snipers carrying a hundred pound pack in 120 degree desert countries, we also have to worry about their diabetes or coronary problems.
19 months ago: What! The USN started programs to weed out us fatties long ago, cost me dearly in time, sweat and promotability. I retired one or two pay grades lower than I could have because my body fat was too high. Not becuase I couldn't do my job, not because I didn't excell in what I did and not becuase I failed the physical fitness tests given yearly, purely becuase my body fat was above thier arbitrary limit I was deemed unqualified to promote. Have no fear, I spent countless hours running, riding, doing PT, all to reduce my fat, but all I got was bad knees, shoulders and physically able to complete the test. Didn't help my fat content by more than a few points. Sure saved them in the end, they don't have to pay much for my retirement since they prevented me from getting promoted to the rank I should have been able to attain. Probably why I encourage young people to join any service but the Navy...... none of the others seem to limit promotion due to body fat alone.

The food served in the military chow halls is not designed to keep a person thin, it is to put calories in their system so they can fight for hours. The chow needs changing more than the soldier, but as Al said, budget cuts....

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.