Economy

Rant

Just a though, or maybe a modest suggestion.........

Posted 5 months ago|4 comments|300 views
Written by
Okay. This is a crazy idea. I don't think it could ever be implemented because it would just take too much co-operation and way too much guts.

What if we just forgave, dissolved, disappeared all debt. I mean ALL debt - sovereign, personal, business, mortgages, the whole shebang.

Over the past 50 years, there is a huge amount of 'paper' wealth that has been developed and leveraged into 'real' wealth. But what does it really mean? How many countries owe money versus are owed money and the same goes down the whole line for businesses, and people. Let's reset to zero.

Here is how I see it. On a personal level, the banks end up out of business. So all my debt is gone and with it, all my savings too. Well for the vast majority of people, they are better off. I now own my home outright as well as my car and my credit cards are paid off. The credit cards are also no good, because the credit card companies went under when their assets disappeared, but....who cares. In the long run aren't we better off?

For businesses, any money on their operating lines of credit, or monies they have borrowed is now wiped out. They just got a freebee (probably used to those) now, any cash balances or monies owed to them are also gone, but on a net-net basis, they are probably okay and if their business model is at all sustainable, most businesses will do okay. Maybe the execs won't be able to get huge bonuses the first year or two, but hey, this would be a great opportunity to see if they are worth it.

For countries, most will end up ahead. If all the countries, states, provinces in the world suddenly have their sovereign debt vanish they can go back to square one and hopefully learn from their mistakes.

In many countries, the existing tax base is designed to service the debt and try to provide service. Just figure out where the federal government in the US would be if the debt service costs vanished.

I know it is a crazy suggestion, but I'm interested in your thoughts. If all you want to do is say I'm some sort of neo-socialist, liberal hack, and nothing else, keep it to yourself. tell me I'm wrong and telly me why. Tell me I'm wrong and tell me what would work.

thanks.
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
5 months ago: It's a novel idea, but they cannot even get congress to approve a measure to forgive student loan debt...
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
5 months ago: OK, more information is needed. Sure, most poeple would come out ahead, considering most people are in debt. I'm not in debt to anyone, and have maintained most of my life that if I can't aford to pay for it, I don't need it. So I personally would not benefit from your plan.

First you need to find out who exactly would be losers in the deal, and what their reaction would be. Of course, with all debt, someone owes the money, and someone is owed the money. So under your plan, my lazy brother would never have to pay me the money he borrowed. I guess that would be a donation of my hard work to him.

Also, would your plan be a complete surprise to everyone? If not, tell me when it going to happen so I can get in debt up to my neck, buying real estate, gold, merchandice, heck, maybe even an island or three. Then when your plan takes effect, I'll get off free and clear.
World wide bankruptcy. Sounds like the ticket.
Perfect Horizon
Perfect Horizon
Chicago, IL
5 months ago: Data won't help. Smaller scale plans similar to this, such as forgiving all student loan debt (which supposedly would help fuel economic growth) cannot even be agreed upon. Banks control the money, money controls the politicians, the politicians will not bite the hand that feeds them. People being in debt is a decision that was made consciously as another system of economic and political control of the people.
5 months ago: No way Jose! Debt is the blood line of commerce. Without it there is no fair trade. However that doesn't mean that all debt is fair. What went wrong over the past couple of decades is that we embraced a global trade system without establishing and enforcing universally accepted fair trade standards. Consequently countries like India and China that have greater and cheaper manpower can monopolize anything and everything. I think if everybody could agree to reassess the current debit to see what its actual worth really is we would find out that it is a lot lower than we currently estimate. Government contracts alone are worth at most two thirds less than their current values

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.