News & Politics

Rant

Is Rick Perry Too Compassionate For The Tea Party?

Posted 7 months ago|8 comments|368 views
Too Compasionate?
Written by
Altruist
Eugene, OR
A couple of weeks ago Rick Perry was the Republican/Tea Party favorite, leading all others with double digits in the polls. Suddenly he is falling back into the pack behind Romney. http://www.star-telegram.com/2011/09/13/...

What happened? What happened is that the Tea Party folk found out that Perry was in favor of allowing undocumented young adults to pay in state tuition. Clearly Perry in not nearly as intolerant as he needs to be, to please the Tea Party.

There are other areas that are nearly blasphemous to the true believers. Rick Perry even advocated the Biblical virtues of taxes and Keynesianism. Perry gave an interview with televangelist James Robison, in which he brought up the story of the Seven Years of Plenty and Famine from the Book of Genesis, and put it into a modern context. In the bible story Joseph was made Prime Minister of Egypt and taxed the farmers 20% so they would have enough grain for the lean times. http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/rick-pe...

When Perry talks about the "Texas Miracle" of creating more jobs than the rest of the nation, Perry doesn't mention that almost all of those jobs were created by big government.

"Between the beginning of 2008 and the end of 2010 (the latest data available), Texas created about 75,000 jobs. That makes it one of the few states with any job creation at all over that time. But federal, state and local government hiring accounted for 115,000 new jobs in Texas, while private industry shed about 40,000 jobs." That is according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. http://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/rick-ne...

Perry isn't the only one who is perceived as too compassionate. Republicans are almost desperate to select anyone but Romney, because Romney started a health care system in Massachusetts that served as a model for Obamacare. http://articles.cnn.com/2009-08-20/polit...

In an atmosphere where Tea Partiers cheer the death penalty, shout Yeah! When asked if the uninsured should be left to die, and boo a brave soldier just because he is gay, being compassionate is the kiss of death. This is kind of strange since most of these folk consider themselves Christians and exemplars of morality.

Of course there are reasonable explanations for all of this behavior. As Perry said, "In Texas, we made the decision that it was in our best interests as a state, economically and otherwise, to have those young people in our institutions of higher learning and becoming educated as part of our skilled workforce,"

The question, he said, was whether undocumented immigrants would be on the "government dole" using state social welfare programs or a subsidized education program that would allow them to become productive members of society. That sounds like the type of rational thing Obama would say.

It also made economic sense for Texas to create jobs by having the government do the hiring to rebuild infrastructure.

Of course most of what Perry advocates does not make much sense, like firing firefighter when the entire state is on fire. Perry's state has the highest percentage of minimum wage workers, the highest number of uninsured, and the most pollution, so it might not be the best place to work. Texas has become the China of America. Is this a good economic model for the nation? http://blog.cesinaction.org/2011/08/17/g...

On the other hand Massachusetts had better job growth than Texas and has the least uninsured in the nation. That may be a record Romney has to run from because it seems that most Republicans/Tea Partiers want America to fail.
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
7 months ago: "Intolerant" my big foot up your.......

Al, we are either a nation of LAWS, or we are not.

PERIOD.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
7 months ago: Al. Does this mean Perry has your vote?

RSG
Don't you know that laws are relative and subjective? And when it is efficacious, hey, what law? It's ok to discriminate, as long as the ones being favored might help you in some way. I'd like to see how many illegal Middle Easterners and North Koreans get to attend college in Texas.
Out Of The Box
Out Of The Box
 Moderator
7 months ago: The Texas Miracle is this. Compared to the other gigantic state, California, which has lost 1,300,000 jobs since 2008......hmmm, but 2 years isn't really a good indicator. We can go back further......

"Texas gained 1.02 million private-sector jobs from May 2000 through May 2008, then lost 359,400 in the past two years, resulting in the overall gain of 661,000 for the decade."

"California is among 33 states that have fewer private-sector jobs today than they did 10 years ago, according to new figures from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

California lost 719,600 private-sector positions between May 2000 and May 2010 -- the second-worst performance by any state. California lost almost 6 percent of its private-sector jobs over that period.

Perhaps more significantly, California has lost almost 1.3 million jobs since its peak in 2007, when the Golden State employed almost 12.7 million. That's a loss of 10.1 percent of its work force in three years."

7 months ago: Someone must be pissed after receiving an I.O.U. in the mail instead of the government dole check.
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
7 months ago: California was home to the Dot Com revolution and had a huge tech presence, but that bubble popped. It wasn't really Schwarzenegger fault. Now Brown has some good ideas to create jobs. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/25...

Likewise when fuel prices doubled, the oil and gas industries that provides much of the income in Texas did pretty well. Texas provides 1/5th of all oil and 1/3rd of the gas of the country and the revenue from those industries is why they can get by with low taxes. None of that was because of Perry.

Perry doesn't get my vote, but I think credit should be given when due. Perry has decent immigration policies. He should be applauded for that and for the good sense to use government to rebuild his infrastructure. Unfortunately he refused to pay for that and just borrowed the money. Texas is going into debt faster than the entire nation and faster than other states. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2011/07...

Likewise I think Romney deserves credit for instituting universal health care although getting the insurance industry out would make it cheaper and more efficient, and I think he deserves credit for raising taxes to balance the budget.
http://2012realityroom.com/2011/09/mitt-...

The few rational ideas in the Republican Party should be encouraged.
7 months ago: Al. You are proving Perry and Romney are not Tea Party Conservatives....which means neither will get my primary vote.

We agree on that one point.

Here comes my candidate. http://www.politico.com/news/stories/101...
7 months ago: Low taxes? Don't you mean a different tax structure?

What? Your pissed because Texas does not have a State Income Tax?

So Al? Since your so aware of how Texas works.

Where does it get it's money?
Altruist
Altruist
Eugene, OR
7 months ago: Red I would love for Palin to be the candidate. Palin Perry would be easiest to beat but Perry Palin would work too.

TCG you get most of your revenue from sales taxes which is the most regressive form of taxes. If Herman Cain won, with his 9-9-9 plan, the poor and middle class would be have huge tax increase, and the millionaires would pay a tiny percentage of the meager amount they are now paying.

This would complete the Conservatives transfer of the nation to the form of 5% aristocracy ruling a nation of 95% serfs. Isn't that what our founders fought against?

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.