Culture & Lifestyle

Rant

Catholicism Needs to be Celibacy Free

Posted 36 months ago|9 comments|1,327 views
VIDEOS
Written by
elguapo
Littleton, CO
The time has come, too much has gone wrong for too long, Catholicism needs to change. This most recent story involving a priest and sexual infidelity has sparked national attention, though this time not the type that could land you behind bars, and cost the church millions in legal fees and settlements. This time, it merely involved a priest giving into his natural attraction and sexual desires, and being caught on camera doing a little kissing and hugging.

Rev. Alberto Cutie is the object of all of this drama. Cutie was the head of Miami archdiocese's international radio network and the head of his parish until he was removed last week after "the Spanish-language magazine TVnotas ran photos of Cutie embracing a woman at a bar and at a beach." Cutie was so well known and liked on the broadcast that he even earned the nickname "Father Oprah" for his superb relationship advice. It turns out that his advice was aided by some research and not simply instincts, as he has admitted that he has had a romantic relationship with the woman in the photos for about two years, involving sex. Outrage!

Cutie has shared that he doesn't want to be the poster boy against celibacy, and shared that he feels that he himself
"fell short." He also shared that he is a proponent of celibacy as a means of commitment to God, and that he simply has fallen in love with the woman and feels torn between his love for her and his love for the Church.

I think Cutie is the best thing to happen to the Church, as far as media attention goes, and I think the Church should run with this. I commend the commitment of so many to show their faith and devoutness to God through celibacy, though I think it is a harmful way to do so. There have been far too many ills that have come from celibacy failed and human sexual desire proving too strong, and this restraint only tends to psychologically damage as well. Don't hear me wrong, I'm not promoting a free love society of the priesthood, but I think it is more than time that this devotion is better placed. I tend towards the Protestant idea that marriage is the completion of a person, when it is entered into faithfully and as a form of worship and devoutness to God. I know that Catholics would dare want to hear a Protestant's mindset on the matter, though I know Protestants are weary of having to hear more allegations and terrible stories involving an issue that should be changed. It is possible to enter into marriage with purity and devotion, if this was a concern, even in today's society. The Catholic church could do a lot to absolve themselves in the minds of many by recognizing the ills of this issue, and the changes that could ease many people's hearts towards them. They can never make up for the wrongs, but they can take steps to work towards positive solutions, and then maybe the great work that is done to care for the forgotten, to reach out to the neglected, and to provide a way in the darkness will be the first thing people think of when they think of the Catholic church.
EMAIL|FLAG THIS POST
COMMENTS
Alex Layton
Alex Layton
 Administrator
Puyallup, WA
36 months ago: I agree. Besides, wasn't the original pope (St. Peter) married?
TheLegendTomWing
TheLegendTomWing
 Administrator
Philadelphia, PA
36 months ago: As a catholic, and a human being, i would rather priests have sexual relations with women, rather than molesting young boys. I wouldn't allow them to marry, but celibacy, in this day and age, seems a bit barbaric.
amishking
amishking
 Moderator
Auburn, NY
36 months ago: Father "Cutie"?

No one at the seminary saw that one coming?
elguapo
elguapo
Littleton, CO
36 months ago: I'm intrigued Tom, why not marry? Not only do I think that would be the more pure and devout, and biblical approach, but I would think that the alternative might become much messier for the church, with the illegitamite children running around due to the disallowance of birth control. I probably don't know enough to keep talking, so...

amishking, this makes me think that Cutie was produced to challenge the system. It's at least more fun to think of the intrigue, Dan Brown could have even more fun with this one.
5 months ago: What must that be like, you know, to have an account open with a site, in this case Rant Rave, and not post a single thing in 32 whole months? You must have completely forgotten about it. Huh? I don't blame you. You use to devote a lot of time to well written essays. It must not be worth it anymore. Have a good life!
Martin Snigg
Martin Snigg
Australia
36 months ago: The RCC is counter cultural.

This age more than any other is completely unqualified to pass judgment on thousands of years of sexual morality or a thousand years of settled tradition re: the priesthood. St Augustine put it around more than anyone. He said it comes down to 'groaning to God for the Grace to serve him in a special capacity with an undivided heart'. If we ask, if we pray the Rosary daily then just as our Lord said - you'll be given it.



This culture is toxic, the author is acting as a mere cypher for it. He could do much better by presenting the case for chastity and going up against that enormous philosophical and cultural apparatus promoting the belief that sex outside of wedlock is morally neutral. It is this machine that is chewing up and spitting out countless young men and women, and destroying families and our society.

We will be ridiculed by future generations for our pornographic culture, girly men in arrested development, fatherless families, gay sex normalising, feticidal and infanticidal legislating, contraceptive nihilism, marriage destroyers, and demographic extinction presiders of Europe and the West.

What legacy do you think our children will thank us for?

RIP the 60's cultural and sexual revolution we're drowning in the blood of 50 million children killed in the womb since 1973!

The time has come, too much has gone wrong for too long the culture needs to change. And we'll need the Catholic Church to lead again to save civilisation or its remnants during a time of barbarism.
Rudi Stettner
Rudi Stettner
 Moderator
36 months ago: I think that in our flawed world, true monogomy is a sufficient achievement for mere mortals. It should be noted that Maronite Catholic priests as well as Eastern Rite Catholics with papal loyalties are permitted to marry. I felt badly for that priest that his normal behavior was considered scandalous. Maybe if he would learn to speak Greek or Aramaic he could have a normal life
35 months ago: Weeeee! I really love it when a real tidbit pokes its head in my side.

This might be an old post to you folks but I just came across it so think I'll revive it a bit.

A priest caught with his hand "in the cookie jar" and not for the first time. Can't blame him, women are our better half and for him to be forced to deny his natural urges is just down right cruel. That he did it for as long as he did is a miracle in itself.

I never have understood the RCC’s standing on a priest or a nun’s need for celibacy. They can’t do their job if they have sex? They are less a figure of respectability once the cherry has been popped? Since when? If that were true, all our most respected leaders would be childless, wife or husband less and celibate and would have started out that way.

As pointed out, one of the “founding fathers” of the RCC was married, before he became a ranking member of the RCC, Peter, or Simon Peter, had a wife and children, she died in martyrdom and he was martyred. Many of the early popes were married either before or while they served.

http://marriage.about.com/od/historyofmarriage/ss/marriedpopes.htm

“Mandatory celibacy was enforced because there was so much political and economic power attached to the papacy especially during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. The Church has adopted celibacy as a matter of discipline, not as a matter of doctrine.”

Didn’t go digging but that basically says that it’s not written that they have to be but it is highly encouraged, especially after the 38th pope wrote a decree that priest should stop cohabitating with their wives.

I agree, it is time for a change, and I’m not Catholic so forget about calling my local priest.

http://marriage.about.com/od/historyofmarriage/ss/marriedpopes_6.htm, check this out, this pope was 180 years old when he died (according to this site).
Siempre Solo
Siempre Solo
Auburn, NY
27 months ago: I’ve been wishing for a long time that some of the old school rantravers like you would start ranting again. I know you probably did it as an income opportunity as did some of the others but it would really be nice to hear from you again. There is no real way to get you to come back unless of course you really wanted to and I certainly hope that you want to. So here is to hoping that you decide to come back even if it is just once or twice to say hello!

Post a Comment
Sign in or sign up to post a comment.